Navigation

    Voting Theory Forum

    • Register
    • Login
    • Search
    • Recent
    • Categories
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups
    1. Home
    2. BlainCellars
    3. Best
    • Profile
    • Following 0
    • Followers 1
    • Topics 1
    • Posts 9
    • Best 4
    • Groups 1

    Best posts made by BlainCellars

    • Scenarios for Evaluating Methods

      I think it would be useful to have a list of scenarios, which can be used to evaluate the performance of various methods of selecting a winner. For each scenario, there should be almost unanimous agreement on the best choice, and the methods will need to be able to make the correct selection. In some situations, there may be two or more outcomes that are pretty much equally desired by the voters.

      For example, in Alex Gendler's TED-Ed video, https://youtu.be/PaxVCsnox_4, it seems to me that everyone will agree that North base is the spaceport location that will result in the greatest amount of satisfaction for the greatest number of people.

      If I'm correct, about the nearly unanimous agreement, then methods can be compared based on how well they do with a variety of scenarios with an established best outcome consensus.

      If I'm wrong, and people cannot agree on what the best choice is, then it seems to me that our quest to find a method is striving to achieve the impossible.

      posted in Single-winner
      BlainCellars
      BlainCellars
    • RE: What Arrow's Impossibility Theorem Really Means

      Is the program that you're using to analyze scenarios and display things available online?

      posted in Research
      BlainCellars
      BlainCellars
    • RE: READ ME: Code of Conduct!

      I thought it was very good. I've never seen anything like the neurodiversity section before. I think it's very good to have, and is well worded.

      posted in Forum Policy and Resources
      BlainCellars
      BlainCellars
    • RE: What Arrow's Impossibility Theorem Really Means

      @tec Your programming skills are FAR beyond what I can do. I started exploring voting options about 7 months ago, and seeing that IRV sometimes selects an outcome that is clearly not the best choice, it occurred to me that looking at the second choice of the ballots of the runner up made sense. That led to a sort of double-elimination approach. Using a spreadsheet to lay out a few scenarios, it appeared that the approach had some promise. Unable to find anyone to help me, I managed to create some php webpages that can be used to evaluate scenarios. Testing with that I found some anomalies so progressed to a hybrid approach. So far, it's checking out just fine.

      I like the visual layout that you provided, and I haven't seen anything with the "indifference lines". It's similar to this: https://ncase.me/ballot/, which you're probably familiar with. I'd like to be able to start with ballot numbers and then have them displayed, rather than being limited to manipulating the image (which I think is fantastic too).

      I was wondering too if your program calculates the distance between the two other options and then sets the second choice as the closest one.

      Here's a link to the crude pages that I put together: https://wethepeople.ca/WTP_IRV-DEp1tester.php

      I would definitely like to collaborate with you on an "evaluation framework".

      posted in Research
      BlainCellars
      BlainCellars