Threaded replies show up both as a threaded reply and at the end of the feed.

[SaraWolk]

I think that's a bit confusing and redundant. Having replies only show up under the comment they are replying to would be better.

[Jack Waugh]

I usually don't expand the list of replies. Consequently, I only see the copy at the end of the feed under the topic. Consequently, I usually only see one copy of each reply.

[SaraWolk]

I think this is still not ideal.

@Marylander , any idea how to change that setting?

[Marylander]

@SaraWolk Unfortunately I do not think that the admin tools provide an easy way to change this. The logical place for it would be under post settings.

A quick google search suggests that there is a plugin to make replies appear only in a nested structure, found here: https://www.npmjs.com/package/nodebb-plugin-threaded-replies

Adding a plugin would be a bit deeper on the technical side than just changing the site settings, however, since it would be a change to the site code, so @Jack-Waugh what do you think about using this plugin?

[Jack Waugh]

@Marylander I guess I can give it a shot. I would first pull an update. And before that, I should probably make double sure I have a good backup. I find it hard to tear myself away from my rewrite of the archive presenter, but maybe should.

[SaraWolk]

@Jack-Waugh @Marylander
Sounds good to me.
Thanks for looking into it. I don't think it's time sensitive or anything, just thought I'd flag it here as a feature request.

Nice to have our categories all sorted out so clearly with a spot for these types of questions.

I haven't had much time to engage here on the forum since we launched, but I've been sending people over and it seems like there are conversations happening!

Looking forward to having more time to invest here soon.